Shakes vs Shingles: Which Cedar Roof Is Right for You?

Nov 7, 2023 | Blog, Cedar Roof Installation, Cedar Shake Roofing, Cedar Shingles, Orange County

Choosing the right roofing material is crucial for Orange County homeowners due to the desire for an upscale and easy-to-maintain home. Cedar roofing fits the desire as it may contribute to higher resale value for homes, where real estate values are often influenced by aesthetic features. The options of cedar shake and cedar shingles both have unique benefits and aesthetics which can make the decision challenging. To narrow down the two, here are the pros and cons between cedar shake and cedar shingles.

cedar roof installation, cedar shingles, Orange County

The Beauty of Cedar

Cedar roofing, be it in the form of shakes or shingles, is known for its natural beauty and enduring charm. The distinctive grain patterns, warm hues, and rustic allure of cedar enhance the visual appeal of any home. Many homeowners opt for cedar to achieve a cozy and inviting atmosphere, appreciating its organic appearance.

Cedar Shake Roofing


  • Durability: Cedar shakes are recognized for their durability and resilience in challenging weather. With proper maintenance, they can endure for 30 years or even longer.
  • Insulation: Cedar shake roofs provide outstanding insulation, assisting in maintaining consistent indoor temperatures and lowering energy expenses.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: The rugged and textured appearance of cedar shakes brings character and charm to your home. With time, they acquire a lovely silver-gray patina that appeals to many homeowners.


  • Maintenance: Cedar shakes require regular maintenance, including cleaning, sealing, and occasional replacement of damaged shakes.
  • Cost: Cedar shake roofing tends to be more expensive than cedar shingles, both in terms of materials and installation.

Cedar Shingle Roofing


  • Longevity: When properly maintained, cedar shingles can last up to 40 years or more.
  • Low Maintenance: Cedar shingles require less maintenance and are easier to repair when damaged when compared to cedar shakes. 
  • Cost: Cedar shingles tend to be more cost-effective than shakes, making them gentler on the budget.
  • Versatility: When flexibility and creativity are desired in a design, cedar shingles can deliver!


  • Thinner Profile: Cedar shingles have a thinner profile than shakes, which may affect insulation properties slightly.
  • Aging: Over time, cedar shingles tend to fade to a silvery gray hue. Some homeowners prefer this look, while others may want to preserve the original color.

cedar roof installation, cedar shake roofing, cedar shingles, Orange County

Transform Your Home

Ultimately, the choice between cedar shake and shingle roofing comes down to your preferences, budget, and maintenance commitment. If you’re looking for a timeless, rustic appearance and are willing to invest in maintenance, cedar shake roofing might be ideal for you. On the other hand, if you prefer a more budget-friendly option with less maintenance, cedar shingles could be the right choice.

To make an informed decision and ensure a quality installation, it’s crucial to work with a trusted roofing contractor in Orange County. Guardian Roofs has a proven track record in the Orange County area, providing expert guidance and top-quality roofing solutions. Whether you opt for cedar shake or shingles, our experienced team can help you achieve the roof of your dreams.

Investing in the right roofing material will not only enhance your home’s curb appeal but also provide protection and comfort for years to come. Choose wisely and enjoy the natural beauty and durability of cedar roofing in Orange County.